This article comes fromDen of Geek UK.
There are very, very light spoilers forPrometheusandAlien: Covenantahead.
I cant think of too many more recent well-deserved sci-fi blockbuster hits thanThe Martian.
I really like the film a lot.
Id also suggest it brought the best out of Ridley Scott.
Ad content continues below
Scott came toThe Martianrelatively late in the day.
Nonetheless, he left behind one of the key reasons for the films success: a rock solid screenplay.
And I think it led to his best film in a long time.
Without going into story spoilers, I thinkAlien: Covenanthas the same problem.
And call it fast.
I wondered, at first, if this was anAlien-centric problem, but I dont think it is.
But, perhaps with the exception ofMatchstick Men, they never felt like complete stories to me.
But improve it Reiner did.
Here was a director who knew what mattered, and pushed his writer to deliver it.
Reiner didnt originate the story, but he instead made sure he could make said story as a film.
I daresay he didnt write a single stage direction or a line of dialogue.
But Reiner, nonetheless, is an excellent storyteller.
This is no hate piece.
I dont think Ridley Scott can do that.
Now, however…. And I do get that.
He doesnt help himself when he talks about being able to crank anotherAlienmovie out next year.
I dont think anyone wants to think of Ridley Scott cranking anything out.
You go to Ratner directing school if you want to crank.
I think Ridley Scotts standards are higher than that.
I wish someone would have interrogated the story before filming began and fixed its problems.
I wish him better scripts.
