Yay or nay?Both.
A yes, and a no, as the ex-demon asks Xander to re-propose after the world doesnt end.
By the beginning of season six, that ring is on her finger.
Yay or nay?Its definitely a no, though it’s possible for you to tell shes tempted.
What more could a girl ask for?
Apparently not, as in the space of four seasons there are at least five proposals.
Yay or nay?According to the order above: yay, yay, nay, yay, yay.
Of the five proposals, only three weddings took place, none of which lasted the show.
Friends and a YouTube clip assure me though that Jack pops the question to Kate in season four.
Yay or nay?She says yes on the YouTube clip.
After that point, youre on your own.
Neither, it turned out.
Joan and Peggy were spot on in their cynicism.
Watching the proposal at a distance, its clear that the answer is a big fat yes.
Yay or nay?A definite yay on both occasions.
